Why “Good Dogs” Still Bite. Understanding Context, Thresholds & Human Error
- Tori Lynn Crowther
- Dec 31, 2025
- 5 min read
Why “Good Dogs” Still Bite
Understanding Context, Thresholds & Human Error
Real-world bite risk — not fear-mongering. Just how experienced walkers stay safe.
This Isn’t About “Aggressive Dogs”
Every professional dog walker has heard it.
“He’s never done that before.”
“She’s such a good dog.”
“He wouldn’t bite — he’s lovely.”
And most of the time, those statements are true.
The problem is this:
Bites don’t happen because dogs are bad. They happen because humans misread context.
This blog isn’t here to scare you.
It’s here to give language and structure to risks you already sense — and to explain why experience reduces incidents far more than obedience ever will.
What “Good Dog” Really Means (and What It Doesn’t)
When clients say “good dog”, they usually mean:
Friendly with people
Sociable with other dogs
Predictable in familiar environments
Easy to live with
Hasn’t bitten so far
These are not meaningless traits — but they are context-bound, not guarantees.
What “good dog” does not mean:
Unlimited tolerance
Emotional resilience under pressure
The ability to cope indefinitely with stress
A fixed, unchanging temperament
Immunity from thresholds or breaking points
Every dog — regardless of breed, age, size, background, or training — has limits.
Professional safety begins the moment we stop treating “goodness” as protection, and start treating it as conditional.
Bites Are Contextual Events, Not Personality Traits
Dogs do not bite out of nowhere.
They bite at the end of a sequence.
That sequence often goes unnoticed because it doesn’t look dramatic. It unfolds:
Across minutes, not seconds
Through subtle changes, not explosions
In the background of an otherwise “normal” walk
What we call a “sudden bite” is usually the final moment of cumulative pressure finally exceeding capacity.
Common Context Stackers on Professional Walks
Multiple dogs with competing needs
Environmental pressure (traffic, cyclists, crowds, noise)
Lead tension (constant, not just sudden)
Arousal from play, anticipation, or frustration
Fatigue — physical or emotional
Time pressure on the handler
Human distraction (phones, conversations, rushing between jobs)
Most bite incidents don’t happen because of one big mistake.
They happen when several manageable factors quietly stack together.
Thresholds: The Line You Don’t See Until It’s Crossed
A threshold is the point at which a dog can no longer process, cope, or respond safely — even if they appeared calm moments earlier.
This is where many walkers get caught out, because thresholds:
Are invisible until exceeded
Change day to day
Drop dramatically under stress
Are influenced by other dogs in the group
Are affected by lack of recovery time
A dog may cope perfectly well with:
One trigger
One dog
One environment
…and fail when those same elements combine.
Experienced walkers don’t just watch behaviour.
They monitor load — how much pressure a dog is carrying before behaviour changes.
Human Error: The Factor We Don’t Like Talking About
This is the uncomfortable part — but it’s also where professional power lives.
Most bite incidents involving dog walkers include at least one human decision point, even when the dog involved is generally stable.
Common contributing factors include:
Assuming consistency means safety
Trusting reputation over real-time assessment
Missing early stress signals because “nothing usually happens”
Overloading walks because logistics demand it
Focusing on managing dogs rather than managing space
Letting routine override curiosity
This isn’t about blame.
It’s about recognising that risk reduction lives in human choices, not dog labels.
Highly experienced walkers aren’t safer because they’re stricter.
They’re safer because they’re less optimistic under pressure.
The Warning Signs Professionals Catch Early
Many early warning signs are dismissed as “nothing” because they don’t look like aggression.
But these signals matter precisely because they appear before escalation:
Stillness where there was previously movement
Sudden fixation on another dog, person, or object
Changes in breathing or mouth tension
Displacement behaviours (sniffing, scratching, shaking off)
Reduced response to familiar cues
Subtle avoidance, leaning away, or increased tension
Experienced walkers don’t wait for growls, snaps, or lunges.
They intervene while the dog is still coping, not once coping has failed.
Why Obedience Doesn’t Prevent Bites
A dog can:
Sit
Recall
Walk politely
Be labelled “well trained”
…and still bite under pressure.
Why?
Because obedience relies on cognitive control, and cognition is the first thing to disappear under emotional overload.
When arousal, stress, or fear rise:
Reaction replaces thought
Muscle memory overrides training
Distance and pressure matter more than cues
Professional safety doesn’t come from commands.
It comes from:
Environmental control
Distance management
Thoughtful group composition
Timing and pacing
Reading the walk, not just the dog
This is why highly trained dogs can still be involved in incidents — and why calm, observant walkers often avoid incidents entirely.
How Experienced Walkers Actually Stay Safe
Not through dominance.
Not through constant correction.
Not through luck.
But through:
Conservative decision-making
Low tolerance for “just this once”
Clear, enforced walk policies
Saying no early — and without guilt
Adjusting routes, timing, and group size
Accepting that prevention is invisible work
The safest walks often look boring:
Fewer dogs
More space
Slower pacing
Fewer “fun” moments
That’s not an accident.
That’s professionalism.
The Most Dangerous Phrase in Dog Walking
“They’ve never done it before.”
Neither had almost every dog involved in a first bite.
Professionalism means preparing for what could happen, not relying on what hasn’t.
Hope is not a safety strategy.
Final Thought: Safety Is a Skill, Not a Trait
Dogs don’t “turn”.
They respond.
Situations change.
Pressure accumulates.
Thresholds are crossed.
When we understand context, thresholds, and our own role in risk, we stop fearing bites — and start preventing them.
That is the difference between someone who walks dogs…
and a professional dog walker.
About Tori Lynn C. & The Dog House
Welcome to The Dog House — my cosy corner of the TLC Canine Crusaders Business Hub. I’m Tori Lynn C., the founder of TLC Dog Walking Limited, mentor to professional dog walkers, and lifelong advocate for dogs and the people who care for them. With over 17 years of hands-on experience in the industry, my mission is to guide you through the realities of running a successful, sustainable dog walking business — from client care and safety to wellbeing, confidence, and professional growth.
The Dog House is where I share the honest, behind-the-scenes conversations we all need: the tricky moments, the funny bits, the business lessons, and the mindset work that keeps us thriving rather than merely surviving. Whether you're just starting out or scaling up, you’ll always find support, guidance, and a friendly nudge forward here.
You’re never alone in this journey — you’re part of a community of canine crusaders.
Comments